Streamers would do effectively to maintain placing Nicole Kidman in the midst of homicide mysteries; she will go from doe-eyed socialite to suspected psychopath with one bat of her outrageous eyelashes. In HBO’s The Undoing, she performs Grace Fraser, whose husband (Hugh Grant) has been arrested for the homicide of his mistress Elena Alves (Matilda De Angelis). But the case isn’t practically as cut-and-dry because the police may need it to be. All the proof factors towards Jonathan Fraser, however he insists he’s harmless, and Grace has discovered herself smack in the midst of a couple of suspicious actions: specifically, strolling by the scene of the crime on the identical night time it occurred. But does that imply she’s the killer?
There are quite a lot of fan theories—some have even began taking polls of who viewers assume the assassin is—however some choices appear extra believable than others because the episodes proceed to roll in. Here’s how issues are searching for the suspects.
Jonathan truly did it.
Perhaps the obvious—and due to this fact least probably—wrongdoer is Jonathan himself. Perhaps he’s been mendacity via his enamel this complete time, convincing his spouse he’s harmless when, actually, he’s a cold-blooded killer. The proof does level to the disgraced physician, and as one Reddit consumer identified, he did the pretty sociopathic deed of sleeping along with his mistress, leaving, stumbling upon her useless physique, after which returning to his house to…have intercourse along with his spouse, then abandon them each the subsequent morning. That’s slightly twisted. So it’s actually attainable, if not particular, that Jonathan has it in him to kill.
Quick spoiler: In the ebook The Undoing relies upon, Jean Hanff Korelitz’s You Should Have Known, Jonathan is certainly the killer. But the sequence has made enormous departures from its supply materials; ebook Jonathan by no means returns after he runs away. The present Jonathan appears way more nuanced—and fairly probably harmless.
Grace is the one in charge.
Another widespread idea is that Grace isn’t solely of sound thoughts, and he or she’s both by chance or purposefully muddled up her thoughts to ease herself of guilt.
“If [Grace has] had 20+ years of experience as a psychologist, I think she would have learned a thing or two about reading people and situations,” one Reddit consumer theorized. “This strange woman started clinging to her seemingly out of nowhere. When she took the walk that was caught on camera, I think that was her heading to Elena’s apartment. Grace can’t remember this because she is struggling with a mental disorder herself.”
But what psychological dysfunction? Is she affected by dissociative episodes? And, even when she is, does she have it in her to brutally homicide her husband’s mistress, particularly when she appears so shocked by what’s occurring round her? I feel this idea makes quite a lot of sense, particularly given a couple of key items of proof: 1) Grace was caught on tape strolling previous the scene of the crime; 2) Grace had a motive for the homicide, and he or she and Elena had a relationship; 3) She appears satisfied her husband couldn’t have accomplished it. But I additionally marvel if Grace’s guilt may be slightly too apparent. Other psychological thrillers have performed this form of sport earlier than, giving us an unreliable protagonist who seems to be the wrongdoer. I fear that, if the sequence goes down that path, the tip consequence will probably be much less satisfying.
Sylvia killed Elena out of jealous fury.
When Jonathan admitted to his therapist that he’d slept with one other girl in addition to Elena, viewers instantly began theorizing about who that may be—the thriller girl may transform vital. And a number of Reddit customers are satisfied his different mistress was Sylvia (Lily Rabe), Grace’s greatest good friend.
“It also took me a bit to realize that Sylvia is the one who could absolutely be the killer and have done so in a fit of rage,” one Reddit consumer wrote. “She’s the one who talks about Elena’s breasts at the committee meeting, points out all the men all over her, knew TOO MUCH about Elena’s patterns at the school (“she sits out there, I saw her months ago, etc.” like she’s been watching the household for awhile), then makes some extent to exit of her solution to [go to] Jonathan’s arraignment. She’s my major suspect now.”
But there are a couple of holes on this idea. One is that Sylvia has hardly proven any indicators of jealousy over Jonathan, and even explicit curiosity in him. He’s already married to her greatest good friend; why would she resolve to kill his mistress? And why, when Jonathan wanted authorized assist after the affair with Elena, would Sylvia be prepared to assist him? I like this idea as a result of it’s sudden, however there are one too many issues for it to be the clear winner simply but.
Franklin killed his son-in-law’s mistress.
What if the true killer is Franklin, Grace’s father? We all know Donald Sutherland is likely one of the greatest within the enterprise at taking part in merciless previous males. And we noticed on the present simply how icily vicious his character can get when threatened. Plus he has some huge cash, and due to this fact assets, so masking up a homicide would hypothetically be simpler for him than, say, Elena’s husband, Fernando. But is that sufficient to convict him, figuratively talking?
Some followers imagine Elena had one other affair, this time with Franklin reasonably than Jonathan. When Franklin heard Elena had moved on to Jonathan, he paid somebody to kill Elena and body Jonathan for it. And maybe Grace walked by the artwork studio the night time of the crime as a result of she suspected her father might need been there.
Here’s what this idea has going for it: Franklin undoubtedly has secrets and techniques. He’s creepy sufficient to appear like a believable assassin. And, if Grace actually has some form of psychological dysfunction, she might be repressing recollections of her father’s conduct.
As one Reddit consumer wrote: “I think that as a child, Grace witnessed or somehow knew that her father killed her mother. She repressed the memory, or he manipulated her into thinking he was innocent and good (Grace’s friends are always saying she only sees good in people. This would also allow her be lied to by Jonathan and ignore his narcissism. It also kinda explains the song in the intro, that she ‘dreams’ about people instead of really seeing them.) Now, she witnessed Elena’s murder and is similarly repressing it or refusing to believe. I also think she had an affair with Elena that she might be repressing?”
Henry’s the assassin.
Here’s the place we get slightly wacky—however nonetheless, technically, believable. This idea is one in every of my favorites, just because it’d be probably the most surprising.
Up till this level, Henry has appeared like nothing however a candy, harmless younger boy. But remember the fact that, when he visited his father in jail, they appeared to move one thing. A notice, maybe? And all these scenes emphasizing Henry’s violin apply appear vital by some means. Is he dissociating, similar as his mom? Perhaps, livid at his father for dishonest, he went and killed Jonathan’s mistress.
One Reddit consumer defined: “I think Henry is the killer and he’s getting his psychopathic behavior not from his father but from his mom. She witnessed her dad’s affairs, killed one of his mistresses and buried that knowledge under the false story of her parents’ perfect marriage.” Another fan added, “The scene where Henry apologizes to Elena’s son (for apparently “bumping into him”) may additionally feed into this idea as he might be apologizing for murdering his mom.”
But such an act is horrible in and of itself, not to mention if it had been dedicated by a younger boy. Would HBO be prepared to take such a danger? As the episodes tick by, we’ll hold counting up the theories till we lastly have a verdict.
This content material is created and maintained by a 3rd social gathering, and imported onto this web page to assist customers present their e mail addresses. You could possibly discover extra details about this and comparable content material at piano.io